Success Stories
Civil Service Institute Pala

Kerala's First & South India's Premier Civil Service Coaching Institute

Enroll in Our Courses

Delhi’s Winter Air Pollution: Does GRAP Deliver Lasting Results?

Why in News?
An analysis of government data by the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA), released on 22 October 2026, found no consistent improvement in Delhi’s winter air quality over the past four years, despite the implementation of the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP). The findings highlight the limitations of short-term emergency measures in addressing the recurring problem of air pollution in Delhi-NCR.
What Is GRAP and How Does It Work?
•    Meaning: The Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP) is a set of short-term emergency measures designed to reduce air pollution through progressively stricter restrictions as air quality deteriorates.
•    Implementation: The Commission for Air Quality Management in National Capital Region and Adjoining Areas (CAQM) announces the applicable stages based on recorded or forecast air quality. State governments implement the directions across Delhi and the relevant National Capital Region districts.
•    Legal framework: GRAP was first notified by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change in January 2017, following Supreme Court directions. The Environment Pollution (Prevention and Control) Authority (EPCA) initially implemented it. In 2021, the CAQM replaced the EPCA and assumed responsibility for implementing GRAP.
•    Progressive restrictions: GRAP has four stages, with restrictions becoming more stringent as pollution increases.
•    •  Stage I – Poor: Delhi AQI of 201–300.
•    •  Stage II – Very Poor: Delhi AQI of 301–400.
•    •  Stage III – Severe: Delhi AQI of 401–450.
•    •  Stage IV – Severe+: Delhi AQI above 450.
•    Examples of measures: Stage I includes stricter enforcement of existing pollution-control norms, including restrictions on the regular use of diesel generator sets. Stage III includes restrictions on construction and demolition activities and certain older vehicles. Stage IV imposes stricter construction restrictions and restricts the entry of trucks into Delhi, subject to specified exemptions.
Why Does Delhi Experience Severe Winter Air Pollution?
•    Unfavourable meteorological conditions: Lower wind speeds and falling temperatures during winter reduce the dispersion of pollutants and contribute to their accumulation near the ground.
•    Stubble burning: Paddy stubble burning during October and November adds to the pollution burden across Delhi-NCR and the wider Indo-Gangetic Plains.
•    Firecracker emissions: Firecrackers during the festive season contribute additional emissions.
•    Other pollution sources: Vehicle emissions and dust further worsen air quality, making winter pollution a combination of multiple sources rather than a single-source problem.
What Does the Recent Evidence Reveal About GRAP’s Effectiveness?
•    Fluctuating winter AQI: According to CREA, Delhi's mean winter Air Quality Index (AQI) rose from 280 in 2022–23 to 304 in 2023–24, fell to 285 in 2024–25 and increased again to 295 in 2025–26.
•    Median AQI follows a similar pattern: The median increased from 294 in 2022–23 to 324 in 2023–24, declined to 289 in 2024–25 and rose again to 305 in 2025–26.
•    No sustained improvement: Both the mean and median AQI for 2025–26 were higher than their 2022–23 levels. Since a higher AQI indicates poorer air quality, the data do not show a consistent downward trend in winter pollution after the 2022 revision of GRAP.
•    Emergency action versus long-term control: GRAP aims to reduce pollution during periods of poor air quality. Its short-term nature means it cannot, by itself, ensure sustained improvement in air quality throughout the year.
•    Recent pollution levels: Delhi's 24-hour average AQI stood at 223, in the 'poor' category, at 4 p.m. on Thursday, compared with 245 a day earlier, according to the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB). This illustrates a daily improvement but does not establish a long-term trend.
What Additional Measures Have Been Introduced?
•    Year-round preparedness versus emergency response: Unlike GRAP, which is activated according to air quality, a Delhi government notification issued on 23 June 2026 introduced certain restrictions for specified winter periods, irrespective of the prevailing AQI.
•    Vehicle restrictions: From 1 November to 31 January, the notification provides for a ban on non-Delhi-registered motor vehicles below Bharat Stage VI (BS-VI) emission standards, with exemptions for electric, compressed natural gas (CNG), emergency and sovereign-duty vehicles.
•    Higher parking charges: Existing parking charges at authorised parking sites are to be doubled from 1 November to 28 February to discourage private vehicle use, except at parking spaces owned and managed by the Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC).
•    Priority of rules: Where the Delhi government's June notification conflicts with GRAP directions, GRAP takes precedence.
How Is Stubble Burning Being Addressed?
•    State-level reviews: The CAQM held separate meetings with the governments of Punjab and Haryana to review measures for preventing paddy stubble burning and controlling other major sources of air pollution.
•    Improved crop-residue management: The Commission emphasised strengthening the crop-residue supply chain and ensuring effective utilisation of available machinery during the peak harvesting season.
•    Monitoring and verification: It called for field verification of burnt-area assessments based on satellite fire alerts and district-wise deployment of drones and low-cost sensors to monitor burning incidents.
•    Circular economy approach: The Commission encouraged greater utilisation of paddy straw as a resource, linking residue management with citizens' well-being and the development of a circular-economy-based industrial ecosystem.
What Is the Way Forward?
•    Move beyond emergency restrictions: GRAP should complement sustained measures addressing vehicle emissions, dust, stubble burning and other major pollution sources.
•    Strengthen inter-State coordination: Delhi, Punjab, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan need coordinated action because winter pollution affects the wider Indo-Gangetic Plains and the National Capital Region.
•    Improve enforcement: Effective implementation, field verification and monitoring are necessary to ensure that announced restrictions translate into action on the ground.
•    Promote sustainable crop-residue utilisation: Better machinery access, stronger supply chains and productive uses for paddy straw can help reduce dependence on emergency action against stubble burning.
•    Evaluate long-term outcomes: Air-quality trends should be assessed across multiple years using mean and median AQI alongside source-specific pollution data, rather than judging success from a single day's improvement.